For my fragrances, I use mostly Peak and Bitter Creek. They both have wonderful 1-ounce sample packs that let me choose a bunch to try for very little investment. And I'm in fly-over country so there's that.
I have read online and heard from other soapers I meet when I visit craft fairs and farmer's markets that NG is very hit-and-miss in their scents so I've never even looked at their offerings.
Some of my favorite smells I like better at one time of year than others:
Paris Twilight screams spring to me. (P)
Spring Rain is also wonderful for the spring and sometimes I like to mix it with fresh mown grass for extra green-ness.
Black Current Vanilla for the earlier part of winter (BC)
Blackberry Musk for the coldest part of winter (BC)
Blackberry Sage for the fall (P)
some headier/stronger florals for high summer such as rose and jasmine - usually in a mix, just like my garden
Although my own potted lemon and lime trees bloom in winter, it's almost too strong in the house so I don't really like neroli for the winter but use it in blends for spring and summer.
I also like Ginger Appletini (BC) and Bitterberry Breezer (BC) and any of the beachy-fruity drinks for spring-into-summer while I tend to use Chardonnay and the like more in late summer-into-fall and Wine and Roses (BC) around valentines day.
And it may seem counter-intuitive but I like Jamaica Me Crazy (P) and Emerald Sea (BC) in winter because WINTER ESCAPE VACATION! - even if it just last the length of a good warm soak in the tub.
I also tend to mix a lot of my own scents and the pick-your-own sample pack deals let me play, play, play to my heart's content. I have a few staples such as oakmoss, three different versions of patchouli, vanilla, and single note fruits, spices, flowers and woods along with some EOs. It really is such fun and a tad bit addictive.
There are a few from Brambleberry that I've a strong yen for such as Kentish Rain and Beau Brummel. I was thinking of possibly treating myself at the givember sale but I think this year they went a different way with the 12 days of Christmas thingy. You are very lucky to be in that corner of the country because when shipping costs more than the product, it does give one pause.