I can't believe no one responded to this. I just saw it as I had some time randomly looking at what's been posted out of boredom, but ehh, I'd be glad to help.
I use the Common Scents all the time.
Sometimes they're spot, drop, hit on the nose, sometimes too light. Your best bet is to order one of their 99 cent sniffies to play around with. They give a generous size for the cost, so you'll get something you can use in a small batch, like M&P, etc...
But they have a lot of different fragrance oils not available anywhere else, so they've been a blessing for me.
Try them out if you get a chance.
But always get a sample first, just to make sure that scent is perfect for you. ^.^