Well it's in the mold! I'm going to cut them into squares for him because it's a pretty deep mold so built up some of the soap and sprinkled with more of the oatmeal along those edges. Seemed to work okay, though we'll see as the days go on huh? I did a 35% water discount and added back the whiskey at trace to bring it back to a full 100% liquid. I ended up scenting it, but very lightly, with an almond/oatmeal fo and a little bit of balsam fir eo. VERY lightly scented. I really hope that some of the whiskey scent is still there, but I have a feeling that soapbuddy's right and the scent is gonna be gone. Whiskey didn't seem to accelerate it much, at least I didn't end up with Soap on stick or spooning it into the mold, poured right in. phew! glad I tried it... I'll let you guys know what happens with it.