I'm all for sharing, and I do, with quite a lot of people on this board and others. However there are a lot more 'over-night soapers' who don't take the time to learn properly before selling, don't take into consideration that people can get harmed from incorrect soap making, use of essential or fragrance oils, etc. Such things happen when you're selling the first soap you've made, especially when you've already commented that it didn't turn out as expected.
I understand this forum is a very 'happy hug' atmosphere, and generally I am happy for that, however surely we don't want to promote the idea that people can start selling as soon as they start making and everything else doesn't matter? Insurance may not be a requirement to sell soap (although neither is contents insurance to own furniture but you'd be silly not to have it), but there is paperwork involved, etc.
I'd much rather see people being taught to
right way to do things, than just giving them a hug, everyone commenting "that looks great" and falsely teaching them they can just do it without a care. Especially given they were already advised to keep it for personal use only.
My post was not aggressive, it was not abusive. I may not have ended with a hug and a kiss, but given the concern for selling a non-tested, remelted/mixed failed soap, I wouldn't expect anyone to be singing their praises. Given how sensitive the author seems to be anyway, I'm not surprised they've taken offence to my post as well.